Compare Mentoring Platforms

Mentorloop vs Mentornity

We’ll break down Mentorloop vs. Mentornity across key factors to help you decide which platform best meets your organization’s needs.

Navigation

Why Organizations Choose Mentorloop

If you don’t want to read the whole article, here are the three main reasons why organizations choose Mentorloop over Mentornity:

And if you want to skip to the complete  comprehensive comparison table, you can click the button below.

Pricing

No wasted seats, no admin hassle

Mentorloop’s pricing structure is transparent and predictable. With set pricing tiers—starting at $299/month for Pro and $1,298/month for Enterprise—organizations can confidently budget for their mentoring initiatives without unexpected costs.

On the other hand, Mentornity’s pricing is based on “active users,” which may seem flexible at first, seeing as no one wants to pay for inactive users. However, this can get tricky to manage. This model requires constant monitoring and manual adjustments by program administrators, who must manually mark users as “active” or “inactive” or even deactivate and replace users to stay within their quota, adding unnecessary complexity and administrative burden.

So how does Mentorloop manage inactive participants? At Mentorloop, we believe that every participant in your program should be active—if they’re not engaged, they shouldn’t be there. (And that’s okay! Not everyone has the time for mentoring all the time.) So instead, Mentorloop focuses on making sure all your participants are engaged in the program using a suite of momentum management and engagement features. 

Mentorloop keeps participants engaged so program coordinators never have to worry about wasted seats or inactive users. This proactive approach ensures organizations get maximum value from their mentoring programs, without the administrative hassle of managing active or inactive users.

User Experience

Better and more accessible with Mentorloop

Mobile Access

For organizations that prioritize accessibility—whether they’re communities, universities, industry associations, or large enterprises with dispersed teams—Mentornity’s lack of a mobile app can be a drawback.

Without mobile access, users who spend long hours away from a computer, such as those working on ships, in hospitals, or in on-site roles, may struggle to stay engaged in their mentoring program. Mentorloop solves this with a dedicated mobile app for both Apple & Android, ensuring that every participant can easily connect, no matter where they are.

User Experience

Designed with ease of use in mind, Mentorloop’s clean, user-friendly dashboard allows program coordinators to effortlessly set up and manage mentoring programs, track key metrics, and facilitate meaningful connections. Participants benefit from a seamless onboarding experience, clear navigation, and powerful features like goals setting, scheduling mentoring meetings, and accessing guidance throught their mentoring journey—all within a beautifully designed and responsive interface.

In contrast, Mentornity’s UI lacks the fluidity that modern users expect. Its interface can be less intuitive, requiring more manual effort from coordinators to manage pairings and track progress.

Mentorloop’s user interface stands out as a superior experience compared to Mentornity, offering a more intuitive, modern, and engaging platform for both program coordinators and participants. 

Mentoring Matches

Smarter, more equitable pairings with Mentorloop

While both platforms have a matching algorithm, Mentornity doesn’t provide clarity on how their algorithm works or what it prioritizes when making matches. 

Mentorloop’s smart matching algorithm is explicitly designed for equity. Rather than simply rating individuals, it considers the entire cohort to ensure balanced match quality across all participants. This approach prevents imbalances where only a select few get the “best” matches, ensuring that every participant benefits from a meaningful mentoring relationship.

 MentornityMentorloop
Matching Types

Mentee-led (with options to approve require admin or mentor approval)
Manual matching
Automatic matching
(available with customizable algorithm)

Self Match
(participant-led)
Manual Match
(coordinator-led)
Blended Matching
Smart Match
(algorithmic matching)

Matching AlgorithmCustomizable but without a specific emphasis on cohort-wide equitability
Customizable equitable matching algorithm—Mentorloop’s smart matching algorithm ensures equitable, high-quality matches across your entire cohort, optimizing compatibility and engagement while ensuring a balanced distribution of match compatibility.

(Smart Match is fully bespoke with Mentorloop Enterprise)

User Data Collection and Handling

Privacy-first with Mentorloop

For organizations that prioritize data privacy and responsible data usage, Mentorloop offers a more thoughtful approach. While Mentornity allows program administrators to collect unlimited profile fields, this extensive data collection can lead to unnecessary personal information being stored—raising concerns about privacy and compliance. At Mentorloop, we believe in collecting only the data that truly matters for creating great mentoring matches, ensuring a streamlined and privacy-conscious experience for all users.

Mentorloop’s AI approach is alo built around data privacy and user control. Mentorloop takes a privacy-first approach by only using meeting notes to generate agendas, ensuring that personal and professional data remain protected. This approach respects user autonomy, allowing participants to shape their mentoring experience without unnecessary data collection.

For organizations prioritizing data security, ethical AI practices, and compliance with privacy regulations, Mentorloop offers a safer and more responsible solution—ensuring that AI enhances mentoring without compromising confidentiality.

Program Setup and Admin

Experience knows best

When it comes to setting up and managing a mentoring program, experience matters more than automation. While Mentornity offers AI-powered program design and management tools, mentoring is ultimately about human connections—something AI can’t fully understand.

Mentorloop is built on the principle that great mentoring comes from experience. Mentorloop’s Program Themes  are developed based on insights from the hundreds of successful programs we’ve helped run over the years. These ensure program coordinators don’t have to don’t have to start from scratch or rely on AI-generated recommendations that lack real-world experience.

Combined with our Program Coordinator Academy, monthly bite-sized training, behavior-based nudges, and real-time program health insights, Mentorloop empowers admins to make informed decisions and keep their programs thriving.

So, while automation can be helpful, mentoring programs succeed when they are thoughtfully designed, actively nurtured, and centered on real human relationships—and that’s where Mentorloop shines.

Momentum Management

Time-based vs Behavior-based

To manage mentoring momentum, Mentornity allows program coordinators to set time-based email reminders to participants, as well as gives them meeting topics, and provides free supportive mentoring content. These are useful tools that help participants stay on track. However, its limitation is that they are all time-triggered, and therefore these reminders may not always be relevant to all participants, especially for programs which allow mentors and mentees to join at different times.

Mentorloop, on the other hand, uses behavior-based Nudges and Milestones—automated prompts triggered by participant actions (or inaction). These ensure that mentoring relationships stay active in real time, with personalized prompts that align with each user’s journey. And with mith multi-channel notifications through Slack, email, and Teams, Mentorloop keeps mentoring programs moving forward without relying on rigid schedules.

Integrations

More ways to connect for every type of organization

When it comes to integrations, Mentornity’s offerings are quite slim. They have no integrations beyond communications platforms and calendars. This means organizationbs that want to  

Mentorloop provides a more extensive and flexible integration suite, powered by our API. Beyond communication tools and HRIS platforms, Mentorloop also integrates with LMS platforms, productivity tools, and CRMs. This ensures that mentoring can be seamlessly embedded into any organization’s existing workflows—whether it’s a business, nonprofit, university, or government body.

Mentorloop also offers the best calendar integration in the business. It allows participants to set their availability, see their mentoring partner’s availability, and schedule one-time or recurring mentoring meetings. This makes it easier for participants to set up and maintain their mentoring sessions without switching between multiple tools or having lengthy back-and-forths with their mentor or mentee to try to find mutually suitable meeting times.

 MentornityMentorloop
Integrations

Zoom
Google Calendar
Microsoft Teams
Google Meet
Jitsi
Outlook

Calendars:
Google Calendar
Office 365
Apple Calendar
Microsoft Exchange
Outlook

Meetings & Communication
:
Zoom
Microsoft Teams
Slack  

HRIS
:
Oracle
Bob
Employment Hero
Rippling
ELMO
UKG

LMS
:
LinkedIn Learning
Go1
UKG

Productivity
:
Workplace
Microsoft Graph
Monday.com

CRM
:
HubSpot
Salesforce
ZOHO

Mentorloop’s API powers all of our integrations.
Don’t see the platform you use? Get in touch!

Resources & Support

Best in class support, no matter what you pay

Both Mentorloop and Mentornity offer free resources and support for program coordinators and participants. Mentornity, however, isn’t clear on whether they offer additional support features or services. 

Mentorloop, on the other hand, provides best-in-class training resources, including the Mentor & Mentee Academy and the Program Coordinator Academy, as well as monthly bitesized training sessions ran by our Customer Success team. With Mentorloop, program coordinators, regardless of what they pay, get direct access to mentoring experts and real-time guidance.

With Mentorloop, you’re getting a true partner in mentoring success, regardless of what you pay.

Community & Social Impact

B Corp Certified

A key distinction between Mentorloop and Mentornity is Mentorloop’s dedication to social impact and making mentoring more accessible to more people.

As a certified B Corporation, Mentorloop upholds the highest standards of social and environmental responsibility. This commitment is evident in our Community Support Program, which offers discounted access to charities, nonprofits, and community organizations—ensuring that impactful mentoring remains within reach for those who need it most.

Qooper, on the other hand, does not currently have any dedicated social impact initiatives or sustainability certifications.

For nonprofits and community groups seeking to provide the benefits of mentoring to their people without the financial strain, Mentorloop’s Community Support Program is the standout choice.

Who is each platform best for?

Mentornity

  • Organizations that value being able to fully customize user profiles with as much information as possible
  • Organizations that prioritize time-based program management over behavioral tracking
  • Organizations that may prefer to allow users to book meetings with others without mentoring matches

Mentorloop

  • Organizations of all sizes looking for cost-effective mentoring
  • Teams that want automated, real-time feedback and insights
  • Companies that prioritize equitable, data-driven matching
  • Organizations that need strong integrations, price and service transparency, and ongoing support

Final Verdict

Mentorloop is the smarter choice

While both Mentorloop and Mentornity offer solid mentoring solutions, Mentorloop provides greater flexibility, accessibility, and value. With equitable matching, automated feedback, a mobile app, and industry-leading integrations, it’s the clear choice for organizations looking to maximize engagement and impact without breaking the budget.

Want to see how Mentorloop can elevate your mentoring program? Get started with a free demo account (no credit card required!) or book a demo today!

Mentorloop vs Mentornity

Comprehensive Comparison Table

Who is it for?

No public information

Built with all organizations in mind—workplaces, member associations, communities, universities, and government.

Pricing

No public information; however third-part websites put their starting price at $289/month

They also offer a free trial for up to 10 participants

Tiered pricing based on “active users”

From $299/month Professional

From $1298/month Enterprise

Access

No mobile app

 Desktop
Mobile App (Apple & Android)

Mentoring Types

Traditional 1:1
Group
Peer
Reverse
Flash

Traditional 1:1
Group
Peer
Reverse
Flash

Matching Types

Mentee-led (with options to approve require admin or mentor approval)
Manual matching
Automatic matching
(available with customizable algorithm)

Self-Match (mentor or mentee-led)
Manual Match (coordinator-led)
Blended Matching
Smart Match (algorithmic matching)

Matching Algorithm

Customizable, however without a specific emphasis on cohort-wide equitability.

Customizable equitable matching algorithm—Mentorloop’s smart matching algorithm ensures equitable, high-quality matches across your entire cohort, optimizing compatibility and engagement while ensuring a balanced distribution of match compatibility.
 
(Smart Match is fully bespoke with Mentorloop Enterprise)

Feedback Collection

Post-meeting feedback
Unlimited forms, polls, and surveys

Sentiment tracking
(Real-time engagement insights)
Automated monthly reports
Actionable insights 
Post-meeting and mentoring quality feedback captured in the tools you already use, via email, Slack, or Teams—seamlessly integrating feedback collection into your ecosystem.

Multi-Lingual Programs

English & Turkish available

✅ Included

English
Simplified Chinese
Spanish
French
Lithuanian
and more

User-friendly Interface

Reporting & Analytics

Live Dashboard
Activity insights
Downloadable reports

Live Dashboard (with actionable Insights)
Real-time Sentiment data
Program health and participant data reports
Reports exports
Monthly digests

AI Tools

AI-powered program design and management services

Privacy-first use of AI: Mentorloop generates agendas via data from meeting notes without feeding your participants’ personal data (in their social media, profiles, or resumes) to AI

Momentum Management

Reminders via automated, timed emails
Meeting topics
Support content for mentors and mentees
Matches not required to book meetings
Program coordinators can add buttons as calls to action for guides and content

Proactive, behaviour-based engagement tools:
Nudges
Milestones
Multi-channel notifications
(including Slack)
Goal setting and tracking

Admin

AI-powered program design
Fully customizable user profiles with unlimited fields
Multi-program capability

Guided DIY setup with Program Themes
Multi-program capability (with Enterprise)

Promotion & Launch Support

Email marketing tools

Ready-to-use media kit for program coordinators
*Live launch webinars

*on Mentorloop Enterprise

Single Sign On
& Social Sign On

SSO login via SAML for HR, LMS, or custom platforms

Both available, including:
Okta
Microsoft Active Directory
Google
LinkedIn

Integrations

Zoom
Google Calendar
Microsoft Teams
Google Meet
Jitsi
Outlook

Meetings & Communication:
Zoom
Microsoft Teams
Slack
Email

HRIS:
Oracle
Bob
Employment Hero
Rippling
ELMO
UKG

Calendars:
Google Calendar
Office 365
Apple Calendar
Microsoft Exchange
Outlook

LMS:
LinkedIn Learning
Go1
UKG

Productivity:
Workplace
Microsoft Graph
Monday.com

CRM:
HubSpot
Salesforce
ZOHO 

Mentorloop’s API powers all of our integrations.
Don’t see the platform you use? Get in touch!

Support & Resources

Custom onboarding steps
Recommended content
Resources for admins and participants

HelpHub
Email
Participant Academy
Mentor and Mentee Training
Program Coordinator Academy
Monthly Bitesized Training
*Customer Service Manager
 
*on Mentorloop Enterprise

G2 Rating

Not in the top 50

#1 in Mentoring

Sustainability & Community Support​

N/A

Mentorloop has been a B Corp since its inception in 2016 and is committed to using business as a force for good

Mentorloop’s Community Support Program has ensured over $500,000 has stayed in the community, giving thousands of individuals around the world access to mentoring connections.

Make the switch

Run your program on the software with the best user experience

Connect with our sales team to discuss how you can seamlessly transfer your program to Mentorloop when you make the switch.

Real, qualified, customer reviews on G2:

Kathlyn R.
Kathlyn R.
Learning and Performance Partner
Mentorloop has truly elevated my experience managing our mentoring program at Informa.

From the start, I’ve been impressed by how easy it is to use—both for admins and for our mentors and mentees. The implementation was seamless, and the features and integrations make it effortless to keep everything running smoothly.

What really sets Mentorloop apart, though, is the outstanding customer support.

Overall, Mentorloop has been a fantastic tool, and I couldn’t be happier.
Malycki M.
Malycki M.
Diversity, Equity and Inclusion Director
Mentorloop and their team are top notch!

While the Mentorloop platform is extremely detailed and provides unique insights, it's also user-friendly!

The team at Mentorloop treated us like we were the most important client they had.

Super easy to get started once we made our choice!
Verified User in Higher Education
Verified User in Higher Education
Mentorloop has revolutionized how we run our programming.

The matching algorithm, calendar integration, loop management, and data analysis are my favorite features.

They are extremely responsive, supportive, and knowledgeable.

Mentorloop is helping us match mentors and mentees with their complex algorithm and making it easy for mentors and mentees to connect and communicate.
Lauren P.
Lauren P.
Culture & Change Partner
Great platform, easy to use with great data insights and backed by excellent client support.

Mentorloop allows us to run a large organisation-wide mentoring scheme with no administrative burden.

The platform is high quality and looks great. The dashboard gives you in depth insights and real time data so that you have all that you need at your fingertips to manage your scheme.

Finally, the customer service is excellent.
Ashish M
Ashish M
Best mentoring tool in business.

Mentorloop has a user-friendly interface so it's very easy to use.

OLX has different departments & employees in different countries. Mentorloop is bridging that gap by proving platform to learn cross culture, nuance of different business.

[Mentorloop] also increased the likelihood of productive relationships and conversations.
Yamini G.
Yamini G.
Excellent Mentoring Engagement Solution

(I like) that it's intuitively designed, and is still simple. The participants register themselves, login to the platform, get matched to their mentor/ mentee via an algorithm, and get started. Quick, simple and easy.

(Mentorloop helps us) enable employees to connect across timezones and geographies, thereby enabling a better 'connect' and best practices exchange. The solution also helps us in retaining the employees and engage them better.
Michelle L.
Michelle L.
The platform is easy to use. It takes all the hard work out of running a mentoring program.

The feature I most appreciate is the automatic surveys, this allows me to keep an eye on the MQS and to gauge what the overall feeling of the program might be from the participants.

Mentorloop helps me run a worldwide mentoring program that is offered to more than 70,000 people at my company. I can be more productive and more efficient at my job thanks to Mentorloop.
Jillian D.
Jillian D.
Excellent software, even better customer support.

The analytics are punchy, easy to understand, and overall helpful for creating, executing and tracking metrics for a mentorship program. The extra tools and resources are helpful for the participants. .

Additionally, Mentorloop's customer service is excellent
Nikki S.
Nikki S.
The platform is easy to use and it's easy to access support from our Mentorloop manager.

We can easily pull numbers and statistics from the platform to manage who we should target campaigns to and we can manage the success of participants' matching through the backend very easily.

It is allowing us to have a great program with little overhead cost. Additionally, it has improved cross-discipline connections across our North and South American offices.

Our previous mentoring programs have all lost momentum until we adopted Mentorloop as our tool.
Louise C.
Louise C.
Mentorloop makes everything super easy.

The best thing about using Mentorloop is it allows for everything to do with our mentoring program to be in one place. The sign-up, matching, building engagement, re-launching a program, all the data, and resources! The support from the team has also been excellent. Can't fault it!

Mentoring through Mentorloop allows us to create opportunities for people to learn from one another and share experiences, cultivate a sense of connection and community.
Angela D.
Angela D.
Excellent mentoring software.

Mentorloop is great for managing our large number of mentoring pairs, giving them support and managing their satisfaction. We have many different cohorts running at once and enables us to manage them easily.

It enables large numbers of mentees and mentors to meet and their relationships be managed and supported. This allows us to support our participants across the globe and reach more of our target audience.
Brooke A.
Brooke A.
Excellent program and software.

The ability to customize the Mentorloop sign-up form was the most beneficial to our constituents, creating meaningful Loops for them to grow with. The in-software features of goal setting, messaging, etc. have also been beneficial in guiding mentor/mentee pairings.

Mentorloop is constantly seeking feedback from each program and participants. Any suggestions I have given for improvements I feel have been taken into consideration!

Ready to see
Mentoring in Motion?

Discover how Mentorloop can help you unlock the mentoring opportunities lying in your organisation.

Trusted by over 150,000 people worldwide