Using Self-determination Theory to Guide Our Mentoring

A woman at her desk contemplating and thinking
On this Page

Mentoring relationships play an integral role in personal and professional development. They provide support, guidance, and opportunities for learning and growth. One way to enhance the effectiveness of mentoring relationships is by incorporating principles from Self-determination Theory (SDT). By understanding and applying these concepts, both mentors and mentees can foster an empowering and meaningful mentoring experience. In this article, we will delve into the various aspects of Self-determination Theory and how it can be used as a framework for mentoring relationships.

What is Self-Determination?

Self-determination Theory is a psychological theory of motivation developed by Edward Deci and Richard Ryan in the 1980s. At its core, SDT posits that human beings have natural, intrinsic tendencies to seek out and engage in activities that promote personal growth and improve self-image.

These tendencies are driven by three basic psychological needs: autonomy, competence, and relatedness.


Autonomy refers to an individual’s need to feel in control of their actions and choices. When an individual has autonomy, they feel empowered to make decisions that align with their personal values and beliefs. For example, a person who values environmental sustainability may choose to live a zero-waste lifestyle and reduce their carbon footprint. By making these choices, they are fulfilling their need for autonomy.


Competence is the need to feel effective and capable in one’s pursuits. When an individual feels competent, they have a sense of mastery over their skills and abilities. For example, a person who enjoys playing the guitar may feel competent when they learn a new song or master a difficult chord progression. By achieving these milestones, they are fulfilling their need for competence.


Relatedness pertains to the need for connection and belonging with others. When an individual feels a sense of relatedness, they feel connected to others and experience a sense of belonging. For example, a person who joins a sports team or a club may feel a sense of relatedness to their teammates or fellow members. By participating in these social activities, they are fulfilling their need for relatedness.

According to SDT, when these three psychological needs are met, individuals tend to be more intrinsically motivated, engaged, and satisfied with their lives. By understanding and fulfilling these needs, individuals can lead more fulfilling and satisfying lives.

Exploring the Benefits of Self-Determination Theory in Mentoring

When these three needs are satisfied (autonomy, competence, and relatedness), individuals are more likely to be motivated, engaged, and successful in their pursuits.

In the context of mentoring, SDT can be a powerful tool for both mentors and mentees. By focusing on the mentee’s autonomy and self-determination, mentors can help their mentees develop a sense of ownership over their goals and actions. This can lead to increased motivation and a stronger sense of self-confidence, as mentees feel empowered to take charge of their own growth and development.

Moreover, SDT can help mentors create a more supportive and collaborative relationship with their mentees. By fostering a sense of relatedness and connection, mentors can create a safe and trusting environment where mentees feel comfortable sharing their thoughts and feelings. This can lead to a deeper understanding of the mentee’s needs and aspirations, which can help mentors tailor their support and guidance accordingly.

Another benefit of SDT in mentoring is that it can promote a growth mindset. Mentees who adopt a self-determined approach are more likely to view challenges and setbacks as opportunities for learning and growth, rather than as failures. This can help them develop resilience and persistence, which are essential qualities for success in any field.

In addition to these benefits, there are also practical considerations for incorporating SDT into mentoring relationships. For example, mentors can use SDT principles to help mentees set meaningful goals, create action plans, and track their progress. Mentors can also provide feedback and support that is tailored to the mentee’s needs and preferences, which can help build trust and rapport.

Overall, the benefits of SDT in mentoring are numerous and compelling. By adopting a self-determined approach, mentors and mentees can create a more supportive, collaborative, and fulfilling relationship that promotes growth and success.

Effective mentoring can lead to the expansion of professional networks, career development opportunities, increased confidence and competence in problem-solving, and higher levels of resilience, well-being, and self-confidence.

Strategies for Incorporating Self-Determination Theory into Mentoring

Self-determination theory is a powerful framework for understanding human motivation and behavior. It suggests that individuals are more likely to engage in activities and pursue goals that align with their intrinsic values and interests. When people feel a sense of autonomy, competence, and relatedness, they are more likely to be self-determined and motivated.

In the context of mentoring, self-determination theory can be a valuable tool for helping mentees achieve their goals and develop their potential. By incorporating the principles of self-determination theory into their mentoring relationships, mentors can create an environment that fosters growth, learning, and self-determination.

One effective strategy for integrating self-determination theory into mentoring is to set collaborative goals. This approach involves working with the mentee to establish goals that are aligned with their interests and values. By taking a collaborative approach to goal-setting, mentors can ensure that the mentee has ownership over the process and is more likely to be motivated to achieve the goals.

Another strategy is to facilitate autonomy-supportive environments. Mentors can encourage mentees to be self-directed and provide choices whenever possible. By creating an environment where mentees feel a sense of autonomy, they are more likely to be intrinsically motivated and engaged in their development.

A third strategy is to focus on competence-building. Mentors can help their mentees develop a sense of competence by breaking down tasks into manageable steps, providing instructional scaffolding, and offering constructive feedback. By helping mentees build their skills and confidence, mentors can increase their sense of competence and motivation.

Cultivating relatedness is another important strategy for incorporating self-determination theory into mentoring. Both mentors and mentees should prioritize building a strong relationship characterized by trust, empathy, and support. This bond can help to fulfill both individuals’ need for relatedness and create a supportive environment for growth and development.

Finally, encouraging self-reflection is a powerful strategy for fostering self-determined behavior. Mentees should regularly engage in self-reflection, with support from their mentors, to gain insight into their strengths, weaknesses, and growth areas. This practice can promote increased self-awareness and help mentees make more self-determined choices.

Overall, incorporating self-determination theory into mentoring can be a powerful way to support mentees’ growth and development. By focusing on collaborative goal-setting, autonomy-supportive environments, competence-building, relatedness, and self-reflection, mentors can create a supportive and empowering environment for their mentees.

A woman at her desk contemplating and thinking

Understanding the Role of Autonomy in Mentoring

Autonomy is a key component of Self-determination Theory and plays a significant role in mentoring relationships. In the context of mentoring, autonomy refers to the degree to which mentees believe they have control over their choices and actions. Research has consistently shown that greater autonomy yields higher levels of motivation, engagement, and satisfaction in various domains, including learning and professional development.

One of the benefits of autonomy in mentoring is that it allows mentees to take ownership of their learning and development. When mentees feel like they are in control of their own progress, they are more likely to be invested in the process and committed to achieving their goals. This can lead to greater success and a stronger sense of accomplishment.

However, autonomy doesn’t mean that mentees are completely on their own. Mentors still play a crucial role in guiding and supporting their mentees, but they do so in a way that empowers the mentee to make their own choices and decisions.

To promote mentee autonomy, mentors should strive to create autonomy-supportive environments. This can be done by providing choices, encouraging self-direction, and validating the mentee’s perspectives and feelings. For example, a mentor might ask their mentee to choose which project they want to work on or encourage them to come up with their own solutions to challenges they encounter.

Another way to foster autonomy is by providing constructive feedback that helps the mentee learn and grow, rather than simply telling them what to do. This can help the mentee develop their own problem-solving skills and build confidence in their abilities.

By fostering a sense of autonomy, mentors can help their mentees develop intrinsic motivation and engagement, leading to more successful outcomes. This is because when mentees feel like they are in control of their own learning and development, they are more likely to be invested in the process and committed to achieving their goals.

Overall, autonomy is a crucial component of effective mentoring relationships. By creating autonomy-supportive environments and empowering mentees to make their own choices and decisions, mentors can help their mentees achieve greater success and develop important skills for lifelong learning and development.

How Self-Determination Theory Enhances the Mentoring Relationship

Utilizing Self-determination Theory (SDT) in mentoring relationships has become increasingly popular due to its potential to significantly enhance the overall experience for both mentors and mentees. SDT is a motivational theory that emphasizes the fulfillment of psychological needs and fostering intrinsic motivation, which can help to create more meaningful, productive, and satisfying mentoring relationships.

One of the key ways that mentors can utilize SDT is by prioritizing building a strong connection with their mentees. By taking the time to get to know their mentees on a personal level, mentors can cultivate a sense of relatedness that can increase mentees’ motivation and commitment to their goals. This connection can also help to establish trust, which is essential for an effective mentoring relationship.

In addition to building a strong connection, mentors can also foster autonomy and competence in their mentees. This means giving mentees the freedom to make decisions and take ownership of their own development, while also providing guidance and support to help them develop the skills and knowledge they need to succeed. By doing so, mentors can facilitate more self-directed and engaged mentees, which can ultimately lead to greater success, growth, and satisfaction within the mentoring relationship.

Another way that SDT can enhance the mentoring relationship is by helping mentors to recognize and address the unique needs and motivations of their mentees. By understanding what motivates their mentees and what their goals are, mentors can tailor their approach to better meet their mentees’ needs. This can help to create a more personalized and effective mentoring experience that is tailored to the mentee’s specific goals and aspirations.

Overall, utilizing SDT in mentoring relationships can have a significant impact on the success and satisfaction of both mentors and mentees. By prioritizing the fulfillment of psychological needs, fostering intrinsic motivation, and tailoring their approach to meet the unique needs of their mentees, mentors can create a more meaningful, productive, and satisfying mentoring experience.

Leading Your Mentoring Journey as a Mentee

As a mentee, embracing the principles of Self-determination Theory can significantly enhance your mentoring experience. By actively engaging in the process, seeking out opportunities for autonomy and competence-building, and cultivating a strong relationship with your mentor, you can maximize your development and drive your own success.

One of the most important aspects of being a mentee is taking an active role in setting goals and identifying areas for growth. While your mentor can provide guidance and support, it is ultimately up to you to determine what you want to achieve through the mentoring relationship. Take some time to reflect on your strengths and weaknesses, as well as your long-term career aspirations. This will help you to identify areas where you could benefit from additional support and guidance.

Another key strategy for leading your mentoring journey is to seek out opportunities to learn and build competence in relevant areas. This might involve attending training sessions, networking with other professionals in your field, or pursuing additional education or certifications. By continuously building your skills and knowledge, you will become a more valuable asset to your organization and increase your chances of achieving your career goals.

Regular communication with your mentor is also critical to the success of your mentoring relationship. Be sure to schedule regular check-ins to discuss your progress, ask for feedback, and address any challenges or concerns that arise. This will help you to stay on track and ensure that you are making the most of your mentor’s expertise and guidance.

As you work towards your goals, it is also important to explore your values and interests to ensure that your career aspirations align with your authentic self. This might involve taking some time to reflect on what truly motivates and inspires you, or seeking out opportunities to explore new areas of interest. By aligning your goals with your personal values and passions, you will be more likely to stay motivated and engaged throughout the mentoring process.

Finally, maintaining a strong and supportive relationship with your mentor is essential to your success as a mentee. Be sure to express your gratitude and appreciation for their time and expertise, and take the time to get to know them on a personal level. By building a strong rapport with your mentor, you will be better equipped to navigate any challenges that arise and maximize the benefits of the mentoring relationship.

  • Take an active role in setting goals and identifying areas for growth.
  • Seek out opportunities to learn and build competence in relevant areas.
  • Communicate regularly with your mentor about your progress and challenges.
  • Explore your values and interests to ensure your goals align with your authentic self.
  • Maintain a strong and supportive relationship with your mentor.

By following these tips, you can take charge of your mentoring journey and achieve your career goals with confidence and clarity.

Encouraging Intrinsic Motivation in Mentoring Through Self-Determination Theory

Intrinsic motivation is characterized by engagement in activities based on enjoyment, satisfaction, or personal growth, rather than external rewards or pressures. Self-determination Theory suggests that when individuals are intrinsically motivated, they are likely to experience higher levels of engagement, persistence, and overall well-being. In the context of mentoring, fostering intrinsic motivation within mentees is crucial for promoting meaningful development and successful outcomes.

By incorporating the principles of Self-determination Theory into the mentoring relationship, mentors can encourage greater intrinsic motivation within their mentees. This can be accomplished by supporting mentee autonomy, fostering competence, and nurturing relatedness. As a result, this approach can yield more engaged, self-directed, and ultimately, more fulfilled mentees within their mentoring experience.

Using self-determination theory as the framework to guide us, mentors’ motivations for engaging as mentors are linked to the fulfillment of basic psychological needs for autonomy, competence, and relatedness.

By embracing Self-determination Theory in mentoring relationships, mentors and mentees alike have the potential to experience substantial benefits, including increased motivation, satisfaction, and success. As both mentors and mentees strive to create an environment characterized by autonomy, competence, and relatedness, they can foster a process of growth and development that is both meaningful and fulfilling.

0 0 votes
Article Rating
Emily Ryan
Emily Ryan
Head of Marketing at Mentorloop. Observing tens of thousands of mentoring relationships, she is passionate about helping people get the most from their mentoring experience. When not writing, you'll find her brewing beer or globe-trotting.

Share this Article

Join the loop

Get updates and learn from the best mentoring programs

continue Learning

Create a culture of mentoring where your people are always learning, supported, and sponsored to success